Welp.

Hasbro has finally responded to my pleas for clarification on what parts of Shards of Equestria they object to. I was holding hope for a miracle, but I got the answer we all pretty much expected: they have a problem with all of it.

The full letter from the lawyers will be posted after the jump but obviously it’s time to make the announcement I was fearing I’d have to make for the last month. Due to legal requests from Hasbro that I have neither the right nor resources to fight, Shards of Equestria is finished.

The link to the Download page has already been removed. I was assuming that offering printable images was the main concern but clearly Hasbro (and mainly Wizards of the Coast) thinks using the actual game mechanics and their card images is the bigger issue. I remain adamant that these cards fell under parody. Hasbro disagrees. I have no ability to fight them on this.

Some people have asked if the project can proceed with wholly original assets. I believe a project like that can, but that wasn’t the project I wanted to do. I don’t have a personal interest in making a set of Pony Magic cards that I have been told can have neither Ponies or Magic in them. There are a host of other fan-made games that are getting off the ground, and I wish them all the best of luck.

I don’t know how much longer the site will stay up but while it stays up I just want to say one more time, thank you, everyone. Thank you for your feedback, your thoughts and your enjoyment of the game, albeit for the very short period it was available.  Regardless of the project being shut down, I still started this with the mindset of of making a custom set that I could play with my friends, and that still exists. There’s a printed-out set of five decks that my friends will still be able to take out and play whenever we want a little break from our normal Magic sessions, and that’s something no lawyer can take from me. Friendship remains Magic.

Dear Mr. [redacted]:

Thank you again for your quick response and patience in awaiting a reply. We have now discussed the matter with both Hasbro and Wizards of the Coast, and regret that, as stated in our original correspondence, although both companies appreciate your enthusiasm for their properties, they must protect their intellectual property rights and therefore deny your request. The fact that you copy, display and distribute the MY LITTLE PONY® and MAGIC: THE GATHERING® trademarks, pony characters, character names, MTG trade dress, Mana symbols and other elements of the two properties is sufficient to violate copyright, trademark and other intellectual property laws. The fact that your cards are available in downloadable format increases the potential danger and impact of that infringement.

Under U.S. copyright law, the copyright holder has the exclusive right to reproduce, distribute, and display the copyrighted work and to create derivative works from it: http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#106. While these exclusive rights are somewhat limited by the fair use doctrine (codified in 17 U.S.C. § 107 – http://www.copyright.gov/title17/92chap1.html#107), your use of Hasbro’s MY LITTLE PONY® and MAGIC: THE GATHERING® elements is not fair use.

“Fan fiction” does not constitute any of the potentially protected fair use purposes, such as criticism, comment, news reporting, teaching, scholarship, or research. That you call your work “parody” does not make it so, nor does it mean that it does not infringe Hasbro and Wizards’ copyrights and trademarks. In fact, your use of the MY LITTLE PONY® and MAGIC: THE GATHERING® elements is not parody at all. Under well-settled law, a parody comments in some way on the copyrighted or trademarked work that it is copying. Your game, on the other hand, does nothing of the sort. Rather you simply use Hasbro’s and Wizards’ intellectual property to create a game from these characters and elements in order to “avoid the drudgery in working up something fresh.” Campbell v. Acuff-Rose Music, Inc., 510 U.S. 569, 580 (1994).
In addition to defining the “permitted purposes” under the fair use doctrine, Section 107 of the U.S. copyright law also sets out four factors to be considered in determining whether or not a particular permitted use is fair:
(1) The purpose and character of the use, including whether such use is of commercial nature or is for nonprofit educational purposes
(2) The nature of the copyrighted work
(3) The amount and substantiality of the portion used in relation to the copyrighted work as a whole
(4) The effect of the use upon the potential market for, or value of, the copyrighted work
Even if your use of the MY LITTLE PONY® and MAGIC: THE GATHERING® elements fell within one of the permitted uses, which we do not believe it does, it still infringes Hasbro’s copyrights under an analysis of the four factors: (1) the nature of the copyrighted work is creative and of the type afforded the highest protection under copyright law; (2) you incorporate virtually the entire copyrighted works, not small or insignificant portions of them; and (3) there is an effect on the potential market for the copyrighted work as both properties are licensed and/or sold in trading card or collectible card form, so your work is a direct substitute for the original works.

We therefore must reiterate our request that you remove the MY LITTLE PONY® and MAGIC: THE GATHERING® elements from the Shards of Equestria game and from your website.

Sincerely,
[redacted]
Counsel for Hasbro, Inc. and Hasbro Studios LLC

 

26 thoughts on “Welp.

  1. Although I’m no expert of the law, I have made a casual study of fair use and parody as it applies in the United States and I do feel that even if you had the resources to fight it, you likely would not have won on the basis of parody. As their letter points out, your work doesn’t provide any particular commentary on either source material.

    Sadly all fan based material is technically illegal. Fair Use and Parody don’t protect your reproductions or mash-ups. However it is generally understood in the creative community that fan-creations are an expression of appreciation and therefor there is a fine line creators need to walk in using the law to stop fan creations like your Shards of Equestria. Josh Wattles explains it rather well: http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=xKBsTUjd910

    All that being said, I’m sorry to hear you weren’t able to work anything out with Hasbro. It was a neat idea. I think I’d like to see the Magic: The Gathering team tackle cross over genres like this, although I don’t suspect it would ever happen. And who knows, perhaps this legal action is a foreshadowing of an awesome Hasbro created MLP card game of some type we can all enjoy.

    Also your work here was impressive. Perhaps we’ll see some other creation of your own design sometime in the future. If so I’d be interested in checking it out.

  2. This is sad… It would be nice if, at least, the site suvived.
    My second thought: You could try to persuade them to print Shards of Equestria officially. They own both Magic and MLP so it could work. What’s more, this edition is well ballanced and gives the feeling of complete edition. We had Unhiged (or how that edition was called) and that other “fun” edition in Magic afterall. So what would be the deal with pony edition? Even if they made smaller release scale, they could make a nice profit on it. They would not need to alter almost anything – you did the whole job just for fun. I know that they won’t do this, but would you mind to ask them anyway?

  3. Well, that just seems unfair. Good thing I downloaded the PDFs, haha. But seriously, it’s just a parody. No one’s gaining anything, except fun.

  4. [Edited: please, please, please do not suggest or allude to activity that could be considered illegal or violating Hasbro's IP. I realize it's an idea a lot of people have but it can't be addressed on this site and I'd like to avoid being liable for it. Thanks. -FIMTG]

  5. I think the main issue here was using real cards with altered artwork, they were beautiful but that was the part that crossed the line seeing how many fan sets exists.
    Thanks for posting this for the fandom as short as it was.

  6. You have my condolences about Hasbro and wizards being jerk :/

    I just hope you keep the files safe somewhere for future generations to enjoy and incase you ever loose them i did a site rip as soon as i read bout this earlyer in Aug or Sept on Eqd :)

  7. God dammit hasbro. You don’t deserve to have the word “bro” in your title. Way to go and ruin something awesome corporate suits.

  8. I agree with pppddd. It would be a shame to let all your work be for nothing here. Selling your concept to Hasbro is a win win for everyone involved. Hasbro protects their copyright and gain money, you get to continue work while making money, and the fans get an enjoyable product. That’s just my thought.

  9. Man, this sucks. I was hoping FIMTG could get off the ground as a legitimate side-game, seeing as how it promotes both MTG and MLP without monetary gain of its own.

    I believe there is a workable case here for the legal use of copyrighted material in “parody” projects in a non-profit setting – that is, they should create a new class of non-profit organization (“fan project”, “parody project”, etc) that allows copyrighted IP to be used in new and interesting ways to benefit the fanbase.

    I can think of many examples of initiatives that would fall perfectly into this category, including the Fallout: Equestria publishing project, the Double Rainboom fan-made episode, and the Pony Kart and Fighting is Magic games. It could be argued that all of these use copyrighted material, for instance from Fallout, MLP itself, and even Nintendo.

    However, if these projects could be organized into verifiable non-profit organizations of some type, then they would be rendered legally harmless to the various copyright holders. If you actually read this far, I salute you. You are awarded 1 internet.

    And a cookie.

  10. :(

    I feel sorry for you. You used all that time, only to have it wasted by legal implications.

    Well, there’s not much you or I can do. Best of luck in your future endeavours.

  11. Pingback: Closing Time | Friendship is Magic: The Gathering – Shards of Equestria

  12. I don’t suppose you could create a google doc or something with a list of the decks and what cards went in them for those of us who downloaded the set before you were forced to take it down? Not new downloads or anything, just a list.

  13. Pingback: Scootareader Looks Into: Copyright Law - |

  14. Pingback: Shards of Equestria Officiallly Closed | EQD Development

  15. It should also be chewy, but not have the texture of
    rubber. So you know that you can do something to create
    your own homemade bubble bath with a good bubble bath recipe.

    It is significant that the water does not touch the chicken breast, else it will boil as an alternative of steam.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

You may use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>